Methanolysis and aminolysis of phenyl chloroformates in acetonitrile h
ave been investigated. The rates are slow due to initial-state stabili
zation by strong resonance electron donation form the phenoxy group. I
n both reactions the large positive values of rho(Y) = 0.8-1.6 and low
Delta H-double dagger and Delta S double dagger values show that the
transition state is strongly associative with little bond breaking. Th
is mechanism is supported by the relatively large solvent isotope effe
ct, k(MeOH)/k(MeOD) congruent to 2.3-2.5, and by the relatively strong
inverse secondary kinetic isotope effect, k(H)/k(D) congruent to 0.74
-0.94, involving deuteriated aniline nucleophiles, in addition to a ne
gative value of rho(XY). The dependence of aniline basicity, beta(X)(b
eta(nuc)) congruent to 0.8, and the rho(X) values of -2.3 are similar
to those corresponding values for the reactions of benzoyl chlorides w
hich have been predicted to react by an associative S(N)2 mechanism. T
hese observations are consistent with a concerted displacement mechani
sm for the methanolysis and aminolysis of phenyl chloroformates.