Models of protandry (1) assume implicitly or explicitly that independe
nt evolution of male and female preadult development times is possible
and (2) assume or assert that protandry should increase in population
s that are univoltine or at least composed of discrete, nonoverlapping
generations. Herein we examine these assumptions in the pitcher-plant
mosquito, Wyeomyia smithii. Heritability and additive generic varianc
e of development time are higher in female than in male W. smithii. Pr
otandry is higher in lines selected for slow development than in lines
selected for fast development or in unselected control lines. Protand
ry is therefore capable of evolving. Contrary to predictions based on
sexual selection, southern populations with multiple, overlapping gene
rations are just as protandrous as northern bi- and univoltine populat
ions with discrete generations. Voltinism and developmental synchrony
of the population do not appear to have been major selective factors i
n the evolution of protandry in W. smithii. We propose that protandry
can be maintained by natural selection in multivoltine populations wit
h overlapping generations as a consequence of sexually dimorphic fitne
ss criteria. Selection should minimize development time in males but m
aximize growth rate in females. In W. smithii, females achieve higher
growth rate than males but also harbor greater genetic variation for d
evelopment time, indicating that selection has, indeed, minimized deve
lopment time to a greater extent in males than in females. We conclude
that if both natural and sexual selection are involved in the mainten
ance of protandry in populations of W. smithii, then their relative im
portance changes with the degree of generation overlap.