Probabilistic phonotactics refers to the relative frequencies of segments a
nd sequences of segments in spoken words. Neighborhood density refers to th
e number of words that are phonologically similar to a given word. Despite
a positive correlation between phonotactic probability and neighborhood den
sity, nonsense words with high probability segments and sequences are respo
nded to more quickly than nonsense words with low probability segments and
sequences, whereas real words occurring in dense similarity neighborhoods a
re responded to more slowly than real words occurring in sparse similarity
neighborhoods. This contradiction may be resolved by hypothesizing that eff
ects of probabilistic phonotactics have a sublexical focus and that effects
of similarity neighborhood density have a lexical focus. The implications
of this hypothesis for models of spoken word recognition are discussed. (C)
1999 Academic Press.