Study objective: To examine the frequency of bronchoscopy performance in a
large tertiary medical center over a period of 8 years.
Design: Retrospective data analysis.
Setting: Academic medical center,
Materials and methods: Using a computerized database of all bronchoscopies
performed between 1991 and 1997, we analyzed trends in (1) the total number
of bronchoscopies; and (2) the numbers of bronchoscopies performed for pat
ients on the basis of the postbronchoscopic diagnosis in the following thre
e main disease groups: AIDS, interstitial lung disease (ILD), and lung canc
er. We measured the following outcomes in the patients of high-volume and l
ow-volume bronchoscopists: procedure length (time to perform procedure), no
ndiagnostic rate, and repeat-bronchoscopy rate. In addition, we compared to
tal admissions, outpatient visits, and insurance status of the patients dur
ing the same period.
Results: In total, 5,580 bronchoscopies were performed. A 17% decline in th
e number of procedures was noted between 1991 and 1997 (from 943 to 783, re
spectively; p < 0.05). The number of AIDS-related bronchoscopies fell from
235 (25% of 943) to 96 (12% of 783), a 59% decline during this period (p <
0.05), There was a corresponding 76% decrease in the number of bronchoscopi
es associated with a diagnosis of Pneumocystis carinii pneumonia (PCP; p <
0.05). During the same period, no similar decrease was noted in the number
of bronchoscopies associated with a diagnosis of ILD or lung cancer. Moreov
er, no significant differences were noted in the procedure length, nondiagn
ostic rate, or repeat-bronchoscopy rate between high-volume and low-volume
bronchoscopists. Although there was no significant change in the number of
total admissions between 1991 and 1997, there was a 48% increase in the num
ber of managed-care patients and a 25.4% increase in the number of Medicaid
health insurance program for California patients between 1991 and 1997.
Conclusions: We noted a significant decline in the number of bronchoscopies
performed between 1991 and 1997. The significant reduction in the number o
f AIDS-associated bronchoscopies accounted for 87% of the decline. Other po
ssible factors include the introduction of a management pathway for the emp
iric treatment of PCP in 1996, a reduction in the number of pulmonary admis
sions, an increase in the number of managed care patients, and a reduction
in the remuneration for the performance of bronchoscopy.