Richtmyer-Meshkov instability is investigated for negative Atwood number an
d two-dimensional sinusoidal perturbations by comparing experiments, numeri
cal simulations and analytic theories. The experiments were conducted on th
e NOVA laser with strong radiatively driven shocks with Mach numbers greate
r than 10. Three different hydrodynamics codes (RAGE, PROMETHEUS and FroriT
ier) reproduce the amplitude evolution and the gross features in the experi
ment while the fine-scale features differ in the different numerical techni
ques. Linearized theories correctly calculate the growth rates at small amp
litude and early time, but fail at large amplitude and late time. A nonline
ar theory using asymptotic matching between the linear theory and a potenti
al flow model shows much better agreement with the late-time and large-ampl
itude growth rates found in the experiments and simulations. We vary the in
cident shock strength and initial perturbation amplitude to study the behav
iour of the simulations and theory and to study the effects of compression
and nonlinearity.