Two expert elementary physical education teachers were interviewed about fo
rmer students who became expert athletes. One expert athlete was a professi
onal basketball player and the other was a college soccer player The conten
t of the interviews was analyzed using manifest and latent techniques. The
results indicated that these teachers identified experience (practice), har
d work (a good attitude), and the cognitive advantage as the major factors
contributing to expertise in these athletes. Those factors distinguished th
ese athletes from other potential experts and from the average student. Tea
chers also suggested that fitness, underlying ability (e.g., quickness, coo
rdination) and skill contributed to expertise but were less important than
the previously mentioned variables. The teachers minimized the contribution
s of maturation and genetics to expertise. The results of the interviews we
re consistent with research published about the development of expertise, e
ven though the teachers had not read specific research journals.