K. Bechter et al., Cerebrospinal fluid filtration in a case of schizophrenia related to "subclinical" Borna disease virus encephalitis, KEY T BRAIN, 1999, pp. 19-35
Schizophrenia may represent a clinical syndrome caused by various etiologie
s and through various pathogenetic pathways. Recent studies suggest viruses
to be a more important cause of schizophrenia than previously thought. Bor
na disease virus (BDV) causes meningoencephalitis or behaviour abnormalitie
s in a broad range of animals, and accumulating data suggest a causal role
of BDV for human neuropsychiatric disorders including schizophrenia. Howeve
r, it is difficult to establish causality in the clinical situation. We add
ressed this problem by detailed investigations over the long term in a sugg
estive single case. Furthermore, we hypothesized a therapeutic effect of ce
rebrospinal fluid filtration (CSFF) in such case comparable to that in ther
apy resistant postinfectious Guillain-Barre syndrome (GBS).
A variety of signs and findings in a 28 years old man indicated a subclinic
al BDV encephalitis being responsible for DSM-IV recent onset schizophrenia
, mainly: elevating BDV specific serum ab's, elevated CSF proteins, slow al
pha-waves and dysrhythmia in EEG on admission (no gross neurologic abnormal
ities). Positive schizophrenic symptoms improved under psychopharmaca medic
ation but not the primary negative symptoms. Therefore the patient was trea
ted by CSFF in two filtration series, each over five days. Outcome was moni
tored by a battery of assessments and tests.
Negative schizophrenic symptoms were rapidly improved under CSFF, in parall
el neurological soft signs, performance in attention tests and EEG; this wa
s similar in time pattern as GBS symptoms improve under CSFF. Clinical stat
us and test performance remained on an improved level after CSFF (p < 0.05)
and improved further spontaneously over the long-term (8 months inpatient,
11 months outpatient observation) to full remission.
We conclude, that eve probably observed the natural course of a mild or 'su
bclinical' BDV-encephalitis-related schizophrenia, which could be ameliorat
ed by psychopharmaca and CSFF. Removing yet partially defined toxic factors
, similar to chat found in GBS, from cerebrospinal fluid may explain clinic
al improvement under CSFF. 'Subclinical' encephalitis by BDV or other virus
es may more frequently underly schizophrenic symptoms than previously detec
ted. Our observation indicates a novel pathogenetic principle in a case of
schizophrenia.