Purpose: The acylfulvenes are a class of antitumor agents derived from the
fungal toxin illudin S. One acylfulvene derivative, MGI 114 (HMAF), demonst
rates marked efficacy in xenograft carcinoma models when compared to the pa
rent acylfulvene or related illudin compounds. The maximum tolerated dose (
MTD) of the two analogs in animals, however, is similar. To help elucidate
the basis of the increased therapeutic efficacy of MGI 114, we determined t
he in vitro cytotoxicity, cellular accumulation and DNA incorporation of th
is drug and compared the results with those from the parent acylfulvene ana
log. Method's: The cytotoxicity of acylfulvene analogs was tested in vitro
against a variety of tumor cell lines. Radiolabeled MGI 114 was used for ce
llular accumulation and DNA incorporation studies. Results: MGI 114 retaine
d relative histiospecific toxicity towards myeloid leukemia and various car
cinoma cell lines previously noted with the parent acylfulvene compound. Ma
rkedly fewer intracellular molecules of MGI 114 were required to kill human
tumor cells in vitro as compared to the parent acylfulvene, indicating tha
t MGI 114 was markedly more toxic on a cellular level. At equitoxic concent
rations, however, the incorporation of MGI 114 into genomic tumor cell DNA
was equivalent to that of acylfulvene. Analysis of cellular accumulation of
MGI 114 into tumor cells revealed a lower Vmax for tumor cells, and a mark
edly lower Vd for diffusion accumulation as compared to acylfulvene. Conclu
sions: The addition of a single methylhydroxyl group to acylfulvene to prod
uce MGI 114 results in a marked increase in cytotoxicity in vitro towards t
umor cells as demonstrated by the reduction in IC50 values. There was a cor
responding decrease in the number of intracellular molecules of MGI 114 req
uired to kill tumor cells, but no quantitative alteration in covalent bindi
ng of the drugs to DNA at equitoxic concentrations. This indicates that cel
lular metabolism plays a role in the in vitro cytotoxicity of MGI 114. The
equivalent incorporation into genomic DNA at equitoxic doses suggests that
DNA damage produced by acylfulvene and MGI 114 is equivalent in regard to c
ellular toxicity and ability to repair DNA. This increased cellular toxicit
y, together with the decrease in diffusion rate, may explain the increased
therapeutic efficacy of MGI 114 as compared to the parent acylfulvene analo
g.