Jj. Egan et al., A randomized, double-blind study comparing the effects of beclomethasone and fluticasone on bone density over two years, EUR RESP J, 13(6), 1999, pp. 1267-1275
Cross-sectional studies have suggested that asthmatic patients receiving hi
gh dose inhaled corticosteroids and intermittent courses of oral corticoste
roids have reduced bone mass. This prospective 2-yr study was undertaken to
evaluate changes in bone density of patients receiving high doses of inhal
ed corticosteroids,
Patients (n=33) (males aged 18-50 yrs, females aged 18-40 yrs) on inhaled c
orticosteroids 1,000-2,000 mu g.day(-1) were randomized in a double-blind f
ashion to either fluticasone propionate (FP) 1,000 mu g.day(-1) or beclomet
hasone dipropionate (BDP) 2,000 mu g.day(-1): In parallel, three open centr
al groups of the same age range were studied: asthmatics (n=8) receiving Lo
w dose inhaled corticosteroids (less than or equal to 400 mu g.day(-1)) (gr
oup A); chronic, severe asthmatics (n=8) receiving oral corticosteroids (gr
eater than or equal to 10 mg day) (group B); and healthy untreated voluntee
rs (n=7) (group C), Bone densitometry scans (quantitative computed tomograp
hy (QCT) of spine; dual X-ray absorptiometry of spine, femoral neck, and si
ngle photon absorptiometry of forearm) were performed at baseline and after
6, 12 and 24 months of treatment. Biochemical bone marker measurements (se
rum osteocalcin, bone alkaline phosphatase, pro-collagen type 1 carboxy ter
minal propeptide, deoxypyridinoline and C-telopeptide of type 1 collagen) w
ere collected every 3 months.
Fifteen FP (mean age 36 yrs, six male) and 9 BDP patients (mean age 33 yrs,
five male); completed the study, At 0 months, mean bone mineral density (B
MD) was lower in patients receiving inhaled corticosteroids (both low dose
and high dose) than in normal volunteers. In the FP-treated group, mean ver
tebral trabecular BMD quantitative computed tomography remained stable with
no evidence of decline, whereas there was some decline in the BDP-treated
group. The treatment difference between FP and BDP was statistically signif
icant in favour of FP for quantitative computed tomography measurements aft
er 12 months (p=0.006) and 24 months (p=0.004),
This study suggests that over 24 months, changes in bone density are minima
l in patients on high-dose inhaled corticosteroids.