T. Kwon et al., An improvement of the password-based authentication protocol (K1P) on security against replay attacks, IEICE TR CO, E82B(7), 1999, pp. 991-997
Authentication protocols are necessary for the receiver of a message to asc
ertain its origin in a distributed environment. Since they exchange cryptog
raphic messages at the beginning of communication, their security is an ess
ential requirement. However, most of the protocols have suffered from sever
al kinds of attacks. A replay attack is one kind of those attacks. Attacker
s could launch it easily by replaying an eavesdropped message. Moreover, th
ere are many types of replay attacks while most of the formal methods are n
ot capable of detecting them. [3] classified various kinds of replay attack
s and proposed a taxonomy. Therefore, it is necessary to verify authenticat
ion protocols deliberately with such a taxonomy for a basis. In this paper,
at first, we give a clear definition and several remarks on replay attacks
. Secondly we review the taxonomy of replay attacks presented in [3], and c
omment on its minor mistake. Finally we examine on the basis of the taxonom
y the password-based authentication protocol, K1P, which was proposed in ou
r earlier papers [1], [2] for protecting weak secrets efficiently. As a res
ult of the examination, we have found that three way mutual K1P shown in [2
] was vulnerable to one of replay attacks. Therefore, we improve three way
K1P on security against the replay attack. Improved three way K1P is secure
against replay attacks as well as guessing attacks and therefore it may be
useful for security services of various communication networks.