Background: While partial left ventriculectomy (PLV) improves left ventricu
lar energetic efficiency, concomitant reduction in mitral regurgitation may
improve ventricular function. Methods: Two hundred ninety-five patients un
dergoing lateral ventricular wall excision between the papillary muscles (l
ateral PLV) and 101 patients with an additional excision of papillary muscl
es and mitral valve replacement (extended PLV) were compared with 65 patien
ts undergoing excision of anterior wall or ventricular aneurysm (anterior P
LV). Results: All patients had reduced functional capacity, New York Heart
Association (NYHA) Class III to IV (3.62 +/- 0.49). Etiologies were cardiom
yopathy (37.3%), coronary artery disease (32.3%), valvular disease (19.7%),
Chagas' disease (7.8%), and others (2.8%). Patients undergoing lateral and
extended PLV had cardiomyopathy as the primary cause of heart failure, whi
le a majority of anterior PLV patients had ischemic disease. Associated pro
cedures included mitral valvuloplasty or replacement (lateral PLV 67%, exte
nded PLV 100%, anterior PLV 40%) and tricuspid annuloplasty (67%, 76%, 28%,
respectively.) In each group after surgery, end-systolic dimension decreas
ed more than end-diastolic dimension despite reduced mitral regurgitation.
Although extended PLV resulted in greater volume reduction and less mitral
regurgitation, these patients had delayed recovery and poor survival. Patie
nts with valvular disease had the most advanced myocardial hypertrophy with
the best survival, while those with Chagas' disease had more severe myocar
ditis, interstitial fibrosis, and the poorest survival. Conclusion: Lateral
PLV improved hemodynamics and functional capacity as much as aneurysmectom
y by reducing ventricular volume and mitral regurgitation. Inclusion and ex
clusion criteria have to be sought to make PLV safer and more effective.