Background: Excessive fruit juice consumption in young children has been as
sociated with nonorganic failure to thrive and short stature in some childr
en and with obesity in others.
Objective: To evaluate, in a sample of healthy young children, whether the
associations between fruit juice intakes and growth parameters differ by th
e type of fruit juice consumed.
Design: Cross-sectional study.
Setting: General primary care health center in upstate New York.
Participants: One hundred sixteen two-year-old children and one hundred sev
en five-year-old children, who were scheduled for a nonacute visit, and the
ir primary care-takers or parents were recruited over a two-year period.
Methods: For 163 children (73% of total), 14 days of dietary records were a
vailable. The dietary records were entered and analyzed using the Nutrition
Data System (NDS). Type of fruit juice was classified according to Nutriti
on Coordinating Center food codes. Height was measured using a Harpenden St
adiometer. Weight was measured using a standard balance beam scale.
Results: The children consumed, on average, 5.5 fluid oz/day of fruit juice
s, which were classified by the NDS software as 35% apple juice, 31% orange
juice, 25% grape juice and 9% other types and/or mixtures of fruit juice.
Children with higher fruit juice intakes had lower total fat, saturated fat
and cholesterol intakes. Child height was inversely related to apple juice
intake (p=0.007) and grape juice intake (p=0.02), after adjustment for chi
ld age, gender and energy intake (excluding fruit juice) and maternal heigh
t. Apple juice intake was correlated with child body mass index (p<0.05) an
d ponderal index (p<0.005), after adjustment for the above covariates. Tota
l cholesterol, LDL-cholesterol, triglyceride and lipoprotein(a) levels were
not related to intakes of any of the fruit juices examined. The children's
ratios of total cholesterol to HDL cholesterol were correlated with grape
juice intakes, while HDL-cholesterol levels were inversely related to grape
juice intakes. There were no significant relationships between fruit juice
intake and measures of anemia (hematocrit or mean corpuscular volume).
Conclusions: The previously reported associations between short stature and
high intakes of fruit juice were observed for intakes of both apple juice
and grape juice. The associations between high fruit juice intakes and obes
ity were observed with apple juice intakes only. Because most of the fruit
juice mixtures were classified as single fruit juices, the findings, especi
ally those with grape juice, need to be cautiously interpreted. High intake
s of fruit juice, however, appear to be associated with growth extremes in
young children. Thus, it would seem prudent for parents and caretakers to m
oderate the fruit juice intakes of their young children.