In this paper we study both market risks and nonmarket risks, without compl
ete markets assumption, and discuss methods of measurement of these risks.
We present and justify a set of four desirable properties for measures of r
isk, and call the measures satisfying these properties "coherent." We exami
ne the measures of risk provided and the related actions required by SPAN,
by the SEC/NASD rules, and by quantile-based methods. We demonstrate the un
iversality of scenario-based methods for providing coherent measures. We of
fer suggestions concerning the SEC method. We also suggest a method to repa
ir the failure of subadditivity of quantile-based methods.