Hypothesis: Transcystic laparoscopic common bile duct exploration (LCBDE) w
ith biliary endoscopy results in excellent long-term clinical outcome and p
atient satisfaction.
Design: Prospective cohort study of unselected patients found to have commo
n bile duct stones during laparoscopic cholecystectomy between October 1989
and April 1998. A mailed survey assessed symptoms, outcome, and satisfacti
on.
Setting: A large community teaching hospital.
Patients: Two hundred seventeen patients with common bile duct stones.
Intervention: Transcystic LCBDE with choledochoscopy.
Main Outcome Measures: Success of LCBDE, morbidity, postoperative symptoms,
and satisfaction.
Results: One hundred sixteen surveys (54%) were returned. Mean follow-up wa
s 60 months. The LCBDE procedure failed in 6 patients and endoscopic retrog
rade cholangiopancreatography was performed in 4 patients (3%). One patient
had unsuspected retained stones. No patient had late recognition of retain
ed stones or a bile duct stricture. Abdominal pain was present in 90 patien
ts (89%) preoperatively and in 29 patients (26%) postoperatively (P = .001)
. The LCBDE procedure reduced 3 specific pain profiles: epigastric, from 47
% (n = 54) to 7% (n = 8); back, from 31% (n = 36) to 6% (n = 7); and should
er, from 18% (n = 21) to 2% (n = 2). When pain persisted, it was different
in character in 15%. All nonpain symptoms (such as nausea, bloating, indige
stion, and gas) were reduced from 78% (n = 91) to 34% (n = 39) (P = .001) e
xcept diarrhea. Diarrhea was present in 24 patients (22%) preoperatively an
d postoperatively, though it was a new postoperative symptom in 11 patients
(11%). One hundred two patients (95%) were satisfied or mostly satisfied w
ith LCBDE.
Conclusions: Pain and nonpain symptoms, while reduced significantly after L
CBDE, may persist. The LCBDE procedure does not result in common bile duct
strictures or a significant rate of retained stones. This relatively new tr
eatment for common bile duct stones is safe and effective.