Purpose. Predicting the toxic potential of compounds to the ocular surface
has depended on the Draize test for the past half century. Alternatives to
Draize testing have recently been sought for a number of reasons. Stress ge
ne expression has emerged as a means of quantifying cellular reaction and,
thus, the toxic potential of the compound in question. This study examines
the expression of the major stress response gene heme oxygenase-1 (HO-1) in
a human corneal epithelial cell line (HCE-T) following challenges with a n
umber of known ocular irritants.
Methods. HCE-T was used to investigate the effect of ocular irritants on ce
ll viability and HO-1 expression. Irritants tested included hydrogen peroxi
de, isopropyl alcohol, sodium hydroxide and trichloroacetic acid. HCE-T cel
ls were grown to 80% confluency and treated with the listed irritants at a
concentration range of 10-100 mu M Cell viability and northern blot analysi
s were performed following a 24 and 48 hr incubation period.
Results. HCE-T cells expressed HO-1 mRNA and HO activity similar to other h
uman cell lines. Northern blot analysis demonstrated that levels of HO-1 mR
NA transcripts increased regularly after exposure to the irritants in a con
centration-dependent manner. Studies on the effect of various inhibitors an
d inducers of HO-1 on cell viability showed that inhibition of HO-1 potenti
ates the cytotoxic effect of ocular irritants. In contrast, pre-induction o
f HO-1 in HCE-T decreases the effect of various irritants on cell viability
.
Conclusions. These results are consistent with the idea that HO-1 mRNA leve
ls may be used as an indicator of toxicity resulting from ocular irritants
and that HCE-T cells respond to stress in a fashion similar to other human
cell lines. This strategy for testing may be important in the development o
f an alternative to Draize testing. The results of this study also suggest
that HO-1 may constitute a part of the protective defense mechanism against
chemical injury.