Mj. Kuby et al., A NEW APPROACH TO PALEOCLIMATIC RESEARCH USING LINEAR-PROGRAMMING, Palaeogeography, palaeoclimatology, palaeoecology, 129(3-4), 1997, pp. 251-267
One of the most frequently attempted correlations in Quaternary resear
ch is between insolation and paleoclimatic data. Yet there are a large
number of insolation time series that could potentially explain a Qua
ternary dataset, individually or in combination. We computed 342 insol
ation time series (varying by latitude, time of year and time of day)
for fitting to four different paleoclimatic records: foraminiferal del
ta(18)O from SPECMAP; temperatures inferred from Vostok, Antarctica ic
e cores; marine accumulation rates of a freshwater diatom, Melosira, o
riginating from tropical Africa lakebeds; and delta(18)O variations in
calcite al Devil's Hole, Nevada. We developed two ''inductive'' linea
r programming models that solve for the weighted combination of insola
tion curves that minimize either the average or maximum residual from
the proxy curve. Each of the four proxy records, lagged and unlagged,
was solved by both model types. On average, our composite insolation c
urves fit the proxy records 48-76% better than does June daily insolat
ion at 60 degrees N, the key insolation curve of the Milankovitch para
digm. Globally, high latitude insolation (60 degrees-70 degrees N and
S) and insolation at specific times of day (noon or non-noon, as oppos
ed to daily) dominated the results. Regionally, the model tended to se
lect insolation curves from absolute latitudes similar to those of the
proxy records. The fact that these results are plausible given known
biophysical processes, combined with the fact that a small number of c
urves repeatedly accounted for a disproportionate share of the explana
tion, suggest strongly that the correlations found are not happenstanc
e, despite the inductive method used.