Double mixing stopped-flow experiments have been performed to study the sta
bility of asymmetric hemoglobin (Hb) hybrids, consisting of a deoxy and a l
iganded dimer. The doubly liganded [deoxy/cyano-met] hybrid (species 21) wa
s reported to have an enhanced stability, with tetramer to dimer dissociati
on requiring over 100 seconds, based on a method that required an incubatio
n of over two days. However, kinetic experiments revealed rapid ligand bind
ing to species 21, as for triply liganded tetramers, which dissociate withi
n a few seconds.
For the present study, [deoxy dimer/azido-met dimer] hybrids are formed wit
hin 200 ms by stopped-flow mixing of dithionite with a solution containing
oxyHb and azido-metHb. The dithionite scavenges oxygen, thus transforming o
xyHb to deoxyHb, and the [oxy dimer/azidomet dimer] hybrid to the asymmetri
c [deoxy/azido-met] hybrid (species 21). After a variable aging time of the
asymmetric hybrids, their allosteric state is probed by CO binding in a se
cond mixing. As previously observed the freshly produced asymmetric hybrids
bind CO rapidly as for R-state Hb. As the hybrids are aged from 0.1 to 10
seconds, the fraction of slow CO binding increases, consistent with a disso
ciation of the asymmetric hybrid to form the more stable deoxy Hb tetramer
which reacts slowly with CO. Control experiments showed a predominantly slo
w phase for deoxy Hb, and fast rebinding for the symmetric hybrids.
The kinetic data can be simulated with a tetramer to dimer dissociation rat
e for species 21 of 1.5/second at 100 mM NaCl (pH 7.2) and 1.9/second at 18
0 mM NaCl (pH 7.4). These values are similar to those reported for liganded
Hb, as opposed to deoxy (T-state) tetramers which dissociate over four ord
ers of magnitude more slowly. As expected from simulations of dimer exchang
e, the observed transition rate depends on the initial fractions of oxy- an
d metHb; this effect is not consistent with a slow R to T transition. These
results, showing a lifetime of about one second for species 21, do not sup
port the symmetry rule which is based on an enhanced stability of the asymm
etric hybrid. (C) 1999 Academic Press.