A. Ladner et M. Brandle, Does direct democracy matter for political parties? An empirical test in the Swiss cantons, PARTY POLIT, 5(3), 1999, pp. 283-302
According to most political scientists and commentators, direct democracy s
eems to weaken political parties. Our empirical analysis in the 26 Swiss ca
ntons shows that this thesis in its general form cannot be maintained. Poli
tical parties in cantons with extensive use of referendums and initiatives
are not in all respects weaker than parties in cantons with little use of d
irect democratic means of participation. On the contrary, direct democracy
goes together with more professional and formalized party organizations. Us
e of direct democracy is associated with more fragmented and volatile party
systems, and with greater support for small parties, but causal interpreta
tions of these relationships are difficult.