Kl. Nichol, The additive benefits of influenza and pneumococcal vaccinations during influenza seasons among elderly persons with chronic lung disease, VACCINE, 17, 1999, pp. S91-S93
Uncertainty regarding the benefits of pneumococcal vaccination may contribu
te to the under use of this vaccine. The present study was conducted to cla
rify the benefits of influenza and pneumococcal vaccinations during 3 influ
enza seasons among elderly persons with chronic lung disease. All elderly m
embers of a large managed care organization with a prior diagnosis of chron
ic lung disease were included in a cohort that was followed over three infl
uenza seasons (1993-1994, 1994-1995, and 1995-1996). Data obtained from the
administrative data bases of the health care organization included baselin
e demographic and health characteristics, influenza vaccination status for
each season, date of pneumococcal vaccination, and outcomes for each season
including hospitalization for pneumonia and death. Cox proportional hazard
s regression and Poisson regression with repeated measures were used to com
pare the risk of outcomes among vaccinated and unvaccinated persons while c
ontrolling for covariates and confounders. During the three influenza seaso
ns, influenza vaccination alone was associated with a 52% reduction (95% CI
18-72) in hospitalizations for pneumonia and a 70% reduction (95% CI 57-89
) in death. Pneumococcal vaccination alone during the three influenza seaso
ns was associated with a 27% reduction (95% CI 13-52) in hospitalizations f
or pneumonia and a 34% reduction (95% CI 6-54) in death. Both vaccinations
together demonstrated additive benefits. When both vaccinations had been re
ceived, there was a 63% reduction (95% CI 29-80) in hospitalizations for pn
eumonia and an 81% reduction (95% CI 68-88) in death versus when neither ha
d been received. These findings suggest pneumococcal vaccination is associa
ted with substantial benefits for elderly persons with chronic lung disease
. Published by Elsevier Science Ltd.