Js. Roden et Jr. Ehleringer, Observations of hydrogen and oxygen isotopes in leaf water confirm the Craig-Gordon model under wide-ranging environmental conditions, PLANT PHYSL, 120(4), 1999, pp. 1165-1173
The Craig-Cordon evaporative enrichment model of the hydrogen (delta D) and
oxygen (delta(18)O) isotopes of water was tested in a controlled-environme
nt gas exchange cuvette over a wide range (400 parts per thousand delta D a
nd 40 parts per thousand delta(18)O) of leaf waters. (Throughout this payer
we use the term "leaf water" to describe the site of evaporation, which sh
ould not be confused with "bulk leaf water" a term used exclusively for unc
orrected measurements obtained from whole leaf water extractions.) Regardle
ss of how the isotopic composition of leaf water was achieved (i.e. by chan
ges in source water, atmospheric vapor delta D or delta(18)O, vapor pressur
e gradients, or combinations of all three), a modified version of the Craig
-Gordon model was shown to be sound in its ability to predict the delta D a
nd delta(18)O values of water at the site of evaporation. The isotopic comp
osition of atmospheric vapor was shown to have profound effects on the delt
a D and delta(18)O of leaf water and its influence was dependent on vapor p
ressure gradients. These results have implications for conditions in which
the isotopic composition of atmospheric vapor is not in equilibrium with so
urce water, such as experimental systems that grow plants under isotopicall
y enriched water regimes. The assumptions of steady state were also tested
and found not to be a major limitation for the utilization of the leaf wate
r model under relatively stable environmental conditions. After a major per
turbation in the delta D and delta(18)O of atmospheric vapor, the leaf reac
hed steady state in approximately 2 h, depending on vapor pressure gradient
s. Following a step change in source water, the leaf achieved steady state
in 24 h, with the vast majority of changes occurring in the first 3 h. Ther
efore, the Craig-Cordon model is a useful tool for understanding the enviro
nmental factors that influence the hydrogen and oxygen isotopic composition
of leaf water as well as the organic matter derived from leaf water.