If economic growth relies upon the extent-of-the-market, then openness will
decrease the connection between initial income and later growth. Alternati
vely, learning-by-doing models suggest that wealth will be more positively
correlated with growth in open economies, because trade causes advanced eco
nomies to specialize in products with more opportunities for learning. We e
xamine twentieth century less developed countries and nineteenth century U.
S. states. In both data sets, there is a much stronger correlation between
growth and initial wealth among closed economies. These findings support th
e importance of the extent-of-the-market, and aggregate demand in fostering
growth.