Background. Aortic valve replacement (AVR) in children is now more commonly
performed with human tissue valves.
Methods. The results of 100 consecutive pediatric AVRs (50 mechanical, 50 h
uman) were reviewed.
Results. There were five perioperative deaths in the mechanical group and o
ne in the human group (p = 0.2). Late complications in the mechanical group
included 4 late deaths, 2 cases of endocarditis, 3 thromboembolic complica
tions, and 10 reoperations on the aortic valve. In the human group, there w
ere no late deaths, 2 reoperations for allograft aortic valve deterioration
(both in Marfan's patients), and 1 reoperation for allograft pulmonary val
ve stenosis. Four-year actuarial survival was 83% in the mechanical group a
nd 98% in the human group (p = 0.02). Four-year actuarial survival free of
all valve-related complications was 61% in the mechanical group and 88% in
the human group (p = 0.008).
Conclusions. Human valves in children requiring AVR provide superior interm
ediate-term survival and freedom from valve-related complications compared
to mechanical valves. Marfan's syndrome may represent a rare remaining cont
raindication for human AVR in children. (C) 1999 by The Society of Thoracic
Surgeons.