The proton adsorption behavior of eight humic acids (HA) and a fulvic acid
(FA) was studied as a function of pH and KNO3 concentration, The emphasis i
s on the comparison of the different humics with respect to their ion bindi
ng properties and on the comparison of two different models to describe the
electrostatic interactions: the Donnan model and the impermeable sphere (I
S) model, Viscosimetric data were used to estimate the hydrodynamic volumes
and radii of the HA molecules, These data were incorporated in the electro
static models and calculations could be carried out without any adjustable
parameter. The Donnan model in combination with hydrodynamic volumes obtain
ed by viscometry cannot adequately describe the electrostatic effects relat
ed to changes of the electrolyte concentration, This model leads to good pr
ediction of the HA behavior if unrealistically large volumes are used for f
ulvics and unrealistically large volume-salt concentration dependencies are
used for humics, The IS model can successfully reproduce experimental prot
on adsorption data with physically realistic radii. The good performance of
the IS model and the poor performance of the Donnan model is directly rela
ted to the fact that the hydrodynamic volumes of the molecules are too smal
l to allow for charge compensation within the molecular limits. The combina
tion of viscometry with the IS model leads to a consistent description of t
he electrostatic in humics and to a consistent way of positioning the maste
r curves, Therefore, the electrostatic potentials and the intrinsic affinit
y distributions of the different samples can be compared on an equal basis.
The similarities in the intrinsic affinity distributions give faith for th
e possibility to develop a generic model to describe the ion binding to hum
ics, (C) 1999 Academic Press.