OBJECTIVE: To determine the prevalence of unrecognized or unsuccessfully tr
eated depression among high utilizers of medical care, and to describe the
relation between depression, medical comorbidities, and resource utilizatio
n.
DESIGN: Survey.
SETTING:Three HMOs located in different geographic regions of the United St
ates.
PATIENTS:A total of 12,773 HMO members were identified as high utilizers. E
ligibility criteria for depression screening were met by 10,461 patients.
MEASUREMENTS AND MAIN RESULTS: Depression status was assessed with the Stru
ctured Clinical Interview for Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental D
isorders, Fourth Edition Depression screening was completed in 7,203 patien
ts who were high utilizers of medical care, of whom 1,465 (20.3%) screened
positive for current major depression or major depression in partial remiss
ion. Among depressed patients, 621 (42.4%) had had a visit with a mental he
alth specialist or a diagnosis of depression or both within the previous 2
years. The prevalence of well-defined medical conditions was the same in pa
tients with and patients without evidence of depression (41.5% vs 41.5%, p
= .87). However, high-utilizing patients who had not made a visit for a non
specific complaint during the previous 2 years were at significantly lower
risk of depression (13.1% vs 22.4%, p < .001). Patients with current depres
sion or depression in partial remission had significantly higher numbers of
annual office visits and hospital days per 1,000 than patients without dep
ression.
CONCLUSIONS:Although there was evidence that mental health problems had pre
viously been recognized in many of the patients, a large percentage of high
utilizers still suffered from active depression that either went unrecogni
zed or was not being treated successfully. Patients who had not made visits
for nonspecific complaints were at significantly lower risk of depression.
Depression among high utilizers was associated with higher resource utiliz
ation.