OBJECTIVE:To critically evaluate the differences between generalist physici
ans and specialists in terms of knowledge, patterns of care, and clinical o
utcomes of care.
METHODS: English-language articles (January 1981 to January 1998) were iden
tified through a MEDLINE search and examination of bibliographies of identi
fied articles. Systematic evaluation of articles relevant to adult medicine
that had a direct comparison between generalist physicians and specialists
in terms of knowledge relative to widely accepted standards of care, patte
rns of care (including use of medications, ancillary services, procedures,
and resource utilization), and outcomes of care was performed.
MAIN RESULTS: In many survey studies, specialists were reported to be more
knowledgeable about conditions encompassed within their specialty. In terms
of overall practice patterns, specialists practicing in their area of expe
rtise were more likely to use medications associated with improved survival
and to comply with routine health maintenance screening guidelines; they u
sed more resources including diagnostic tests, procedures, and longer hospi
tal stays. In the:he limited number of studies examining the care of patien
ts with acute myocardial infarction, acute nonhemorrhagic stroke, and asthm
a, specialists had superior outcomes compared with generalists.
CONCLUSIONS: There is evidence in the literature suggesting differences bet
ween specialists and generalists in terms of knowledge, patterns of care, a
nd clinical outcomes of care for a broad range of diseases. In published st
udies, specialists were generally more knowledgeable about their area of ex
pertise and quicker to adopt new and effective treatments than generalists.
More research is needed to examine whether these patterns of care translat
e into superior outcomes for patients. Further work is also needed to delin
eate the components of care for which generalists and specialists should be
responsible, in order to provide the highest quality of care to patients w
hile most effectively utilizing existing physician manpower.