Ag. Marsh et Dt. Manahan, A method for accurate measurements of the respiration rates of marine invertebrate embryos and larvae, MAR ECOL-PR, 184, 1999, pp. 1-10
Measurements of respiration rates are essential to quantify the energy requ
irements of embryos and larvae. Here we describe a 'mu BOD' method that emp
loys small (<1 ml) Biological Oxygen Demand (BOD) glass vials in which embr
yos and larvae are incubated. A decrease in oxygen concentration is measure
d by injecting seawater from each vial into the measurement chamber of a st
andard polarographic oxygen sensor. This mu BOD method was used to measure
respiration rates of larvae of the sea urchin Strongylocentrotus purpuratus
(at 15 degrees C) and embryos and larvae of 2 Antarctic echinoderms, the s
ea urchin Sterechinus neumayeri and the seastar Odontaster validus (both at
-1.5 degrees C). For validation, a comparison of different methods was per
formed with embryos and larvae of S. neumayeri. The mu BOD method gave resu
lts for respiration rates during development that were equivalent to those
obtained with either coulometric capacitance respirometry or standard Winkl
er's titrations of large (300 ml) BOD bottles. Currently, the most common m
ethod for measuring respiration rates of invertebrate embryos and larvae is
to place them in small respiration chambers and continuously monitor oxyge
n tension with a polarographic oxygen sensor (POS). However, respiration ra
tes for embryos and larvae of S, neumayeri were underestimated when standar
d POS measurements were compared to the measurements made with either mu BO
D, Winkler's titrations or coulometric capacitance respirometry, A comparis
on of the mu BOD and POS methods during early development in S, neumayeri r
esulted in different estimates of 920 and 343 mu J, respectively, for the t
otal energetic cost of embryogenesis to gastrulation, illustrating that the
POS error can be as great as 63 %. The mu BOD method is accurate for micro
-respiration measurements of invertebrate embryos and larvae as well as bei
ng simple to operate and appropriate for field work.