Pischke (1995) has argued that imperfect information may account for the fa
ilure of Hall's permanent income hypothesis to explain the behaviour of agg
regate consumption. We identify the restrictions that Pischke's theory plac
es on the dynamics of aggregate consumption and test them using quarterly d
ata for the United Kingdom and United Stales. Our results suggest that, whi
le Pischke's model explains some features of the data which the Hall model
cannot, it is formally rejected.