Rb. Hayes et al., Nutritionally complete prepared meal plan to reduce cardiovascular risk factors: A randomized clinical trial, J AM DIET A, 99(9), 1999, pp. 1077-1083
Objective To compare a nutritionally complete prepared meal plan that meets
national dietary guidelines to usual-care dietary therapy for hypertension
, dyslipidemia, and glycemic control.
Design Randomized, controlled trial.
Subjects/setting Outpatients with hypertension, dyslipidemia, or diabetes m
ellitus (n=251) were recruited at 6 medical centers in the United States an
d Canada.
Intervention The prepared meal plan, which was developed by university-base
d nutrition and cardiovascular scientists and food technologists at Campbel
l's Center for Nutrition & Wellness (CCNW), provided the optimal levels of
macronutrients and micronutrients recommended for cardiovascular risk reduc
tion in a variety of prepackaged meals and snacks. After a 4-week pretrial
period to assess baseline state, participants were randomized to the CCNW p
lan or "usual-care" diet for 10 weeks.
Main outcome measures Blood pressure, carbohydrate metabolism, lipoproteins
, homocysteine, weight, nutrient intake, compliance.
Statistical analyses performed Repeated measures analysis of variance.
Results Lipoproteins, carbohydrate metabolism, blood pressure, and weight i
mproved on both plans. Mean differences (+/-standard deviation) between bas
eline and follow-up for the CCNW plan and the usual-care plan, respectively
, were total cholesterol, -0.41+/-0.64 and -0.20+/-0.50 mmol/L (between-gro
up P<.01); plasma glucose, -0.7+/-1.7 and -0.3+/-1.3 mmol/L (P<.05); systol
ic blood pressure, -5.2+/-10.0 and -4.7+/-9.0 mm Hg (P=.67), diastolic bloo
d pressure, -3.8+/-5.9 and -2.2+/-5.5 mm Hg (P<.05); and homocysteine, -1.3
+/-3.8 and 0.2+/-3.4 mu mol/L (P<.01). The CCNW plan led to greater weight
loss than the usual-care diet (-5.5+/-3.8 kg vs 3.0+/-3.2 kg, P<.0001).
Applications/conclusion The nutritionally complete CCNW plan offers greater
improvements in lipids, blood sugars, homocysteine, and weight loss than u
sual-care diet therapy. This prepackaged comprehensive nutrition program ca
n augment both the prescription and practice of optimal dietary therapy.