Dl. Bennett et Hb. Nielsen, Gauge couplings calculated from multiple point criticality yield alpha(-l)=137 +/- 9: At last, the elusive case of U(1), INT J MOD P, 14(21), 1999, pp. 3313-3385
We calculate the U(1) continuum gauge coupling using the values of action p
arameters coinciding with the multiple point. This is a point in the phase
diagram of a lattice gauge theory where a maximum number of phases convene.
We obtain for the running inverse fine structure constant the values alpha
(1)(-1) = 56 +/- 5 and alpha(1)(-1) = 99 +/- 5 at the Planck scale and the
Mt scale, respectively. The gauge group underlying the phase diagram in whi
ch we seek multiple point parameters is what we call the Anti-grand-unified
theory (AGUT) gauge group SMG(3), which is the Cartesian product of three
Standard Model Groups (SMG's). There is one SMG factor for each of the N-ge
n = 3 generations of quarks and leptons. In our model, this gauge group SMG
(3) is the predecessor of the usual SMG. The latter arises as the diagonal
subgroup surviving the Planck scale breakdown of SMG(3). This breakdown lea
ds to a weakening of the U(1) coupling by a N-gen-related factor. For N-gen
= 3, this factor would be N-gen (N-gen + 1)/2 = 6 if phase transitions bet
ween all the phases convening at the multiple point were purely second orde
r. The factor N-gen (N-gen + 1)/2 = 6 corresponds to the six gauge-invarian
t combinations of the N-gen = 3 different U(1)'s that give action contribut
ions that are second order in F-mu nu. The factor analogous to this N-gen (
N-gen + 1)/2 = 6 in the case of the earlier considered non-Abelian coupling
s reduced to the factor N-gen = 3 because action terms quadratic in F-mu nu
that arise as contributions from two different of the N-gen = 3 SMG factor
s of SMG(3) are forbidden by the requirement of gauge symmetry.
Actually we seek the multiple point in the phase diagram of the gauge group
U(1)3 as a simplifying approximation to the desired gauge group SMG(3). Th
e most important correction obtained from using multiple point parameter va
lues tin a multiparameter phase diagram instead of the single critical para
meter value obtained, say, in the one-dimensional phase diagram of a Wilson
action) comes from the effect of including the influence of also having at
this point phases confined solely w.r.t. discrete subgroups. In particular
, what matters is that the degree of first-orderness is taken into account
in making the transition from these latter phases at the multiple point to
the totally Coulomb-like phase. This gives rise to a discontinuity Delta ga
mma(eff) in an effective parameter gamma(eff). Using our calculated value o
f the quantity Delta gamma(eff), we calculate the above-mentioned weakening
factor to be more like 6.5 instead of the N-gen (N-gen + 1)/2 = 6, as woul
d be the case if all multiple point transitions were purely second order. U
sing this same Delta gamma(eff), we also calculate the continuum U(1) coupl
ing corresponding to the multiple point of a single U(1). The product of th
is latter and the weakening factor of about 6.5 yields our Planck scale pre
diction for the continuum U(1) gauge coupling, i.e. the multiple point crit
ical coupling of the diagonal subgroup of U(1)(3) is an element of SMG(3).
Combining this with the results of earlier work on the non-Abelian gauge co
uplings leads to our prediction of alpha(-1) = 137 +/- 9 as the value for t
he fine structure constant at low energies.