Ab. Woodland et al., Equations of state for Fe32+Fe23+Si3O12 "skiagite" garnet and Fe2SiO4-Fe3O4 spinel solid solutions, J GEO R-SOL, 104(B9), 1999, pp. 20049-20058
The equations of state of Fe32+Fe23+Si3O12, or "skiagite" garnet, and two F
e2SiO4-Fe3O4 spinel solid solutions were determined from room temperature h
ydrostatic compression experiments up to 11 GPa performed at the European S
ynchrotron Radiation Facility. These data indicate that there are no first-
order phase transitions or changes in compression mechanism in skiagite gar
net or Fe3+-bearing silicate spinel solid solutions up to Il GPa at room te
mperature. Skiagite garnet has an isothermal bulk modulus K-0T= 157.4(3.0)
Cpa and a pressure derivative of the isothermal bulk modulus K'(0T)=6.7(8),
where numbers in parentheses represent 1 estimated standard deviation of t
hese values. Combination of this result with those for other silicate garne
ts reveals an inverse linear relationship between the octahedral cation-oxy
gen (Y-O) bond length and the bulk modulus. The dominating effect of the oc
tahedral site on the bulk compression of garnet can be understood by consid
ering that the octahedral-tetrahedral network has no rigid unit modes and t
hat no cation substitution occurs on the tetrahedral sites in these garnets
. It is apparent that the incorporation of Fe3+ and Cr acts to lower the bu
lk modulus of aluminosilicate garnets. Consideration of the effect of compr
ession on the molar volume results in nonsystematic changes in calculated o
xygen fugacity for garnet-bearing mantle peridotites that equilibrated at h
igh pressures. The pressure-volume data obtained from two Fe3+-bearing sili
cate spinel solid solutions with compositions X-fay = 0.45 and X-fay = 0.57
(fay, fayalite component) yielded similar enough; values of K-0T and K'(0T
) to warrant a combined refinement with the data points scaled to the appro
priate zero-pressure volumes. This gave K-0T = 168.9(1.2) GPa and K'(0T) =
5.7(1.2) with chi(W)(2) = 4.6 (weighted chi(2)) and K-0T = 175.5(1.4) GPa w
hen K'(0T) is fixed equal to 4 (chi(W)(2) = 4.9), Our solid solutions have
significantly lower bulk moduli than either magnetite or Fe2SiO4 spinel end
-members or indeed many other spinels.