The long-standing controversy regarding whether Giardia intestinalis is a s
ingle species prevalent in both human and animal hosts or a species complex
consisting of morphologically similar organisms that differ in host range
and other biotypic characteristics is an issue with important medical, vete
rinary, and environmental management implications. In the past decade, high
ly distinct genotypes (some apparently confined to particular host groups)
have been identified by genetic analysis of samples isolated from different
host species. The aim of this study was to undertake a phylogenetic analys
is of G. intestinalis that were representative of all known major genetic g
roups and compare them with other Giardia species, viz. G. ardeae, G. muris
, and G. microti. Segments from four "housekeeping" genes (specifying gluta
mate dehydrogenase, triose phosphate isomerase, elongation factor 1 alpha,
and 18S ribosomal RNA) were examined by analysis of 0.48-0.69-kb nucleotide
sequences determined from DNA amplified in polymerase chain reactions from
each locus. In addition, isolates were compared by allozymic analysis of e
lectrophoretic data obtained for 21 enzymes representing 23 gene loci. The
results obtained from these independent techniques and different loci were
essentially congruous. Analyses using G. ardeae and/or G. muris as outgroup
s supported the monophyly of G. intestinalis and also showed that this spec
ies includes genotypes that represent at least seven deeply rooted lineages
, herein designated assemblages A-G. Inclusion of G. microti in the analysi
s of 18S rRNA sequence data demonstrated the monophyly of Giardia with the
same median body morphology but did not support the monophyly of G. intesti
nalis, instead placing G. microti within G. intestinalis. The findings supp
ort the hypothesis that G. intestinalis is a species complex and suggest th
at G. microti is a member of this complex.