Vr. Kumar et al., CHILDREN AND ADULTS IN CARDIOPULMONARY ARREST - ARE ADVANCED LIFE-SUPPORT GUIDELINES FOLLOWED IN THE PREHOSPITAL SETTING, Annals of emergency medicine, 29(6), 1997, pp. 743-747
Study objective: To compare the proportions of children and adults in
whom advanced life support (ALS) guidelines for prehospital management
of cardiopulmonary arrest. Methods: We conducted a retrospective cros
s-sectional study of an urban EMS system and an urban ED. We studied 1
41 consecutive patients (47 children and 94 adults, matched by date of
presentation) in cardiopulmonary arrest who were transported to the p
ediatric and adult EDs by AIS-trained prehospital providers (paramedic
s) between January 1992 and July 1995. We reviewed ambulance trip repo
rts and ED records to determine when and which interventions were perf
ormed in the prehospital setting. Significance of differences between
the groups was determined with Fisher's exact test and Student's t tes
t. Results: In 47 children (median age, 1 year; range, 2 days to 15 ye
ars) and 94 adults (median age, 67 years; range, 16 to 95 years), puls
elessness was documented at the time of the initial response of the AL
S provider. Basic life support was performed in all patients. Among th
e 21 children and 7 adults who were not intubated, intubation was atte
mpted in 13 children (62%) and in 6 adults (86%) (P=.26). Among the 29
children and 16 adults in whom intravascular access was not establish
ed, unsuccessful attempts to establish access were made in 1 child (3%
) and in 15 adults (94%) (P=.0001). Among the 30 children and 91 adult
s who were intubated, in whom intravascular access was established, or
both, epinephrine was not administered to 12 children (40%) and 6 adu
lts (7%) (P<.0001). Conclusion: In our study population endotracheal i
ntubation, intravascular access, and administration of epinephrine wer
e attempted and performed significantly less frequently in children th
an in adults. Given the relative infrequency with which ALS providers
encounter children in cardiopulmonary arrest, they need additional tra
ining to maintain their skills.