Rk. Raley et Rr. Rindfuss, The effect of respondent's kinship position on reported levels of integrational contact: USA and Japan, POP RES POL, 18(3), 1999, pp. 279-298
Intergenerational relationships are a topic of general concern to social sc
ientists because of the importance of the family for individual's well-bein
g, especially in times of crisis. Hence, a considerable amount of research
on relationships between parents and their adult children has been publishe
d in a broad array of social science journals. Most of this research examin
es intergenerational relationships from the perspective of only one generat
ion and implicitly assumes that we would get the same results if we were to
examine the relationships from the point of view of other family members.
In societies where there are strong norms regarding kin contact, this assum
ption is likely to be invalid. This research examines reported levels of fa
ce-to-face contact among kin in the USA and Japan, and tests whether these
reports are systematically different far respondents in some kinship positi
ons than in others. The results show that norms favoring patrilineal contac
t in Japan can produce reporting bias. In Japan, married daughters tend to
underreport levels of contact with their parents. In the USA, children-in-l
aw report lower levels of visiting.