We have performed density functional calculations using cluster models of t
he C(100), Si(100) and Ge(100) surfaces, We find that the ground-state geom
etry is strongly dependent upon the constraints imposed during geometry opt
imization and also can be affected significantly by the cluster size in the
range of cluster sizes typically used for such calculations. Our calculati
ons show that the ground state has a symmetric dimer geometry for the carbo
n surface and an asymmetric diner geometry for the silicon and germanium su
rfaces. This is in agreement with the latest first-principles slab calculat
ions and, for silicon, is also consistent with experimental results. Severa
l previous cluster calculations favour a symmetric dimer on the silicon sur
face. Our results show that inappropriate geometry constraints or inadequat
e cluster size may have led to a symmetric ground state in these calculatio
ns. The change in energy of the cluster as a function of the dimer buckling
angle is also investigated for all three surfaces, We find that dimer buck
ing is driven by a lowering of the kinetic energy of the electrons, We also
observed that the dimer electron density is qualitatively different betwee
n the carbon surface on the one hand and the silicon and germanium surfaces
on the other. We rationalize this in terms of the small core size of the c
arbon atom and relate it to the different groundstate dimer symmetry found
for the C(100) surface as opposed to Si(100) and Ge(100) surfaces. Copyrigh
t (C) 1999 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.