M. Page et al., CUTICULAR HYDROCARBONS AS CHEMOTAXONOMIC CHARACTERS OF PINE ENGRAVER BEETLES (IPS SPP) IN THE GRANDICOLLIS SUBGENERIC GROUP, Journal of chemical ecology, 23(4), 1997, pp. 1053-1099
Cuticular hydrocarbons were extracted, identified, and evaluated as ch
emotaxonomic characters from all species of adult Ips pine engraver be
etles in the grandicollis subgeneric group. The grandicollis group con
sists of Ips grandicollis (Eichhoff), I. cribricollis (Eichhoff), I. l
econtei Swaine, I. montanus (Eichhoff), I. paraconfusus Lanier, I. con
fusus (LeConte), and I. hoppingi Lanier. In order to provide outgroups
for a phylogenetic analysis, cuticular hydrocarbons were also analyze
d from Orthotomicus caelatus (Eichhoff), I. latidens (LeConte) (latide
ns subgeneric group), and I. pini (Say) (pini subgeneric group). Two h
undred forty-eight hydrocarbon components were identified by gas chrom
atography-mass spectrometry. The members of the grandicollis group pro
vided 206 of these compounds. The components represented eight classes
: n-alkanes, alkenes, alkadienes, terminally branched methylalkanes, i
nternally branched methylalkanes, dimethylalkanes, trimethylalkanes, a
nd tetramethylalkanes. Different populations of O. caelatus, I. grandi
collis, I. lecontei, I. montanus, I. paraconfusus, I. confusus, and I.
hoppingi provided no evidence for interpopulational variation in cuti
cular hydrocarbons. Single populations only were analyzed for I. latid
ens, I. pini, and I. cribricollis. Sexual dimorphism in cuticular hydr
ocarbons occurred only in I. lecontei where females produced eight uni
que components with a pentatriacontane parent chain. Several phylogene
tic analyses based on hydrocarbon phenotypes agreed in general with th
e established morphologically based system of relatedness and with pub
lished phylogenies reconstructed from prorein and nucleic acid charact
ers. Nearly all hydrocarbon analyses suggested a close relationship be
tween I. grandicollis and I. cribricollis; between I. lecontei and I.
montanus; and among the sibling species I. paraconfusus, I. confusus,
and I. hoppingi. The presence or absence of specific n-alkanes (n-doco
sane, n-triacontane); certain dimethylalkanes (terminally branched wit
h octacosane and triacontane parent chains and internally branched wit
h heptacosane, hentriacontane, and docotriacontane parent chains); and
3,7,11-; 3,7,15-trimethylheptacosane permit facile discrimination of
I. paraconfusus, I. confusus, and I. hoppingi. These three sibling spe
cies are difficult to resolve by external morphology. These data suppo
rt the species status of I. hoppingi rather than it being considered a
host race of the I. confusus complex. They also support the species s
tatus of I. cribricollis rather than it being considered part of I. gr
andicollis. In contrast to other published phylogenies reconstructed f
rom molecular data, phylogenies reconstructed from cuticular hydrocarb
ons repeatedly place I. lecontei as an integral part of the grandicoll
is subgeneric group. Thus, cuticular hydrocarbon and pheromone alcohol
composition of I. lecontei support its inclusion in the grandicollis
subgeneric group.