Tr. Oliver et P. Paulshaheen, TRANSLATING IDEAS INTO ACTIONS - ENTREPRENEURIAL LEADERSHIP IN STATE HEALTH-CARE REFORMS, Journal of health politics, policy and law, 22(3), 1997, pp. 721-788
States are often touted as 'laboratories'' for developing national sol
utions to social problems. In this article we examine the appropriaten
ess of this metaphor for comprehensive health care reform and attempt
to draw lessons about policy innovation from recent state actions. We
present evidence from six states that enacted major pieces of health c
are legislation in the late 1980s or early 1990s: Massachusetts, Orego
n, Florida, Minnesota, Vermont, and Washington State. The variation in
design casts doubt on the proposition that states can invent plans an
d programs for other states and the federal government to adopt for th
emselves. Instead, we argue that it is more accurate to think of state
s as specialized political markets in which individuals and groups dev
elop and promote innovative products. We examine the factors that migh
t create receptive markets for comprehensive health care reforms and c
onclude that the critical factor these states shared in common was ski
lled and committed leadership from ''policy entrepreneurs'' who formul
ated the plans for system reform and prominent ''investors'' who contr
ibuted substantial political capital to the development of the reforms
. We illustrate different strategies that leaders in these states used
to carry out the entrepreneurial tasks of identifying a market opport
unity, designing an innovation, attracting political investment, marke
ting the innovation, and monitoring its early production.