We studied secondary succession in two subtropical evergreen broad-leaved f
orests near Shanghai, China that had been harvested 2-60 years earlier. Shr
ubs were thinned in one of the forests to about 60% of their original densi
ty for the first 20 years after harvesting. The other was not disturbed aft
er harvesting. Five stands were sampled in each forest. Species composition
and richness varied little during succession. Biomass, soil organic matter
, total soil nitrogen, and soil water all increased with time. Soil organic
matter and total nitrogen were significantly less in thinned forest than i
n undisturbed forests, but soil moisture did not vary with shrub thinning.
Total tree density did not change over time, suggesting that species replac
ements were not driven by self-thinning. The eventual replacement of shrubs
by trees occurred because shrub density decreased whereas tree density rem
ained constant and tree mass increased.