Digestibility of canola protein products derived from the physical, enzymatic and chemical processing of commercial canola meal in rainbow trout Oncorhynchus mykiss (Walbaum) held in fresh water
Sa. Mwachireya et al., Digestibility of canola protein products derived from the physical, enzymatic and chemical processing of commercial canola meal in rainbow trout Oncorhynchus mykiss (Walbaum) held in fresh water, AQUAC NUTR, 5(2), 1999, pp. 73-82
This study was undertaken to assess the relative importance of nutrient com
position and levels of antinutritional factors present in various canola pr
otein products derived from the processing of commercial canola meal (CCM)
on digestibility in rainbow trout held in 9.9-11 degrees C fresh water.
Laboratory sieving of CCM (SCM) reduced levels of crude fibre, cellulose an
d hemicellulose by 31.6%, 16.6% and 56.4%, respectively. Aqueous methanol-a
mmonia washing of sieved canola meal (ACM) increased neutral detergent fibr
e (NDF, insoluble dietary fibre) and phytate, and dramatically decreased le
vels of total glucosinolates (> 88%) and phenolic compounds (approximate to
59%) relative to CCM. Further treatment of ACM with phytase in acidified (
pH 5.0) aqueous media (PCM), followed by filtration, increased levels of cr
ude protein, crude fibre and NDF, and decreased levels of phytate (33%), ph
enolic compounds (81%) and glucosinolates (below detection limit) relative
to CCM. Additional treatment of PCM with carbohydrase enzymes (SP-249 and/o
r Alpha Gal, an oligosaccharide-degrading enzyme) further elevated levels o
f NDF, cellulase, protein (SP-249 only) and indispensable amino acids (SP-2
49/Alpha Gal), and concurrently decreased levels of phytate relative to PCM
. An industrial source of canola protein isolate (CPI), produced by first e
xtracting CCM with aqueous salt solution and then recovering the protein fr
action, had the best nutrient composition and lowest levels of the antinutr
itional factors mentioned above. The processing protocols had slight or mar
ked negative effects (ACM and SP-249/Alpha Gal) on apparent dry matter dige
stibility. Protein digestibility coefficients were unaltered in the laborat
ory-processed products, except for the products treated with SP-249 and SP-
249/Alpha-Gal. In these cases, the protein digestibility coefficients (77.4
% and 79.5%) were significantly below that found for CCM (88.1%). With two
of the treatments, ACM and SP-249/Alpha-Gal, processing depressed :DE. In c
ontrast, the DE level in CPI (20.6 MJ kg(-1)) and the digestibility coeffic
ients for dry matter (77.1%) and protein (97.6%) were high.
We conclude that high levels of fibre, either alone or together with phytat
e, have the greatest adverse effects on the digestibility of canola protein
products for rainbow trout. The high digestibility of CPI and its low cont
ent of antinutritional factors may also enable this protein product to be a
n excellent substitute for premium quality fish meal in diets for salmonids
.