The emergence of division of labour in forced associations of normally solitary ant queens

We tested the hypothesis that division of labour is an inescapable property of social groups, rather than an evolutionary event separate from socialit y We propose a variance-based emergent property model in which division of labour can spontaneously emerge when (1) individuals in a group vary in the ir intrinsic sensitivity to stimuli for a given task, and (2) the performan ce of a task by individuals with higher task sensitivities reduces performa nce of the task by the other group members. Under these conditions, the ind ividuals with higher sensitivity become the task specialists. To determine if division of labour can occur in the absence of direct selection, we crea ted artificial foundress associations (groups of queens during nest establi shment) of the ant Pogonomyrmex barbatus, which has no history of cooperati ve colony founding. We compared the incidence of task specialization in thi s species to that in Pogonomyrmex californicus, in which foundress associat ions commonly occur. Levels of task specialization for nest excavation were high in both species, arguing that division of labour emerges in groups re gardless of evolutionary history. Consistent with the variance-based model, the role of nest excavation specialist in P. barbatus foundress associatio ns could be predicted by both (1) differences in excavation roles in prior pairs and (2) variation in excavation activity while solitary. Furthermore, the assumption of the excavator role by one foundress dramatically reduced the performance of that task by the other foundress of the pair. We also f ound a strong negative relationship between excavation activity and foundre ss survival in P. barbatus, suggesting that division of labour in this cont ext may act as a constraint on social evolution.