A number of "suicide genes" have been developed as safety switches for gene
therapy vectors or as potential inducible cytotoxic agents for hyperprolif
erative disorders, such as cancer or restenosis. However, most of these app
roaches have relied on foreign proteins, such as HSV thymidine kinase, that
primarily target rapidly dividing cells. In contrast, novel artificial dea
th switches based on chemical inducers of dimerization (CIDs) and endogenou
s proapoptotic molecules function efficiently in both dividing and nondivid
ing cells. In this approach, lipid-permeable, nontoxic CIDs are used to con
ditionally cross-link target proteins that are fused to CID-binding domains
(CBDs), thus activating signaling cascades leading to apoptosis. In previo
us reports, CID-regulated Fas and caspases 1, 3, 8, and 9 were described. S
ince the maximum efficacy of these artificial death switches requires low b
asal and high specific activity, we have optimized these death switches for
three parameters: (1) extent of oligomerization, (2) spacing between CBDs
and target proteins, and (3) intracellular localization. We describe improv
ed conditional Fas and caspase 1, 3, 8, and 9 alleles that function at subn
anomolar levels of the CID AP1903 to trigger apoptosis. Further, we demonst
rate for the first time that oligomerization of the death effector domain o
f the Fas-associated protein, FADD, is sufficient to trigger apoptosis, sug
gesting that the primary function of FADD, like that of Apaf-1, is oligomer
ization of associated caspases. Finally, we demonstrate that nuclear-target
ed caspases 1, 3, and 8 can trigger apoptosis efficiently, implying that th
e cleavage of nuclear targets is sufficient for apoptosis.