M. Adler et al., PROGNOSTIC EVALUATION OF PATIENTS WITH PARENCHYMAL CIRRHOSIS - PROPOSAL OF A NEW SIMPLE SCORE, Journal of hepatology, 26(3), 1997, pp. 642-649
Background/Aims: The current shortage of organs makes it desirable to
establish the prognosis of patients with cirrhosis in order to assess
priority for liver transplantation. Methods: We compared the utility o
f two exogenous tests (aminopyrine breath test and lidocaine metaboliz
ation test), two clinical parameters (encephalopathy, ascites), 18 end
ogenous tests and five scores (Pugh, Merkel, Orrego Adler, Pignon) for
predicting 1-year mortality in patients with parenchymal cirrhosis, R
etrospective (n=49 out of 63 patients) and prospective (n=38 out of 46
patients) series were included, Univariate, multivariate, receiver op
erator curves and survival curves were employed. Results: We found tha
t endogenous tests were more discriminant than exogenous tests, The be
st parameters of the univariate analysis (encephalopathy, bilirubin, a
lkaline phosphatase, cholinesterase and bile acids) and their 25th and
75th percentiles were included in an additive new score which turned
out to be superior to the five other scores, Prospectively, the sensit
ivity of our new score compared to the Pugh score was 82% versus 95% (
NS) and the specificity was 89% versus 56% (p<0.01). Conclusions: Our
new simple score appears to be very powerful for predicting prognosis
at 1 year for patients with cirrhosis and should be evaluated in other
centers.