This paper examines the consequences of changes in the organization's marke
t position on its market share, testing arguments of inertia and regression
toward the mean and taking into account recent methodological critiques of
studies on the consequences of organizational change. A study of format ch
ange in the U.S. radio industry, 1984-1992, shows that changes cause perfor
mance to decline, as inertia theory predicts, but this is moderated by orga
nizational size and performance before the change, so change can be benefic
ial for low-performing organizations but may be harmful for large and succe
ssful organizations.