Assuming that the L-shaped three-dimensional structure of tRNA is an archit
ectural framework allowing the proper presentation of identity nucleotides
to aminoacyl-tRNA synthetases implies that altered and/or simplified RNA ar
chitectures can fulfill this role and be functional substrates of these enz
ymes, provided they contain correctly located identity elements. In this wo
rk, this paradigm was submitted to new experimental verification. Yeast asp
artyl-tRNA synthetase was the model synthetase, and the extent to which the
canonical structural framework of cognate tRNA(Asp) can be altered without
losing its ability to be aminoacylated was investigated. Three novel archi
tectures recognized by the synthetase were found. The first resembles that
of metazoan mitochondrial tRNA(Ser) lacking the D-arm, The second lacks bot
h the D- and T-arms, and the 5'-strand of the amino acid acceptor arm. The
third structure is a construct in which the acceptor and anticodon helices
are joined by two connectors. Aspartylation specificity of these RNAs is ve
rified by the loss of aminoacylation activity upon mutation of the putative
identity residues. Kinetic data indicate that the first two architectures
are mimics of the whole rRNA(Asp) molecule, while the third one behaves as
an aspartate minihelix mimic. Results confirm the primordial role of the di
scriminator nucleotide G73 in aspartylation and demonstrate that neither a
helical structure in the acceptor domain nor the presence of a D- or T-arm
is mandatory for specific aspartylation, but that activity relies on the pr
esence of the cognate aspartate GUC sequence in the anticodon loop.