To explore how altered plasticity genes affect whole-plant phenotypes and p
lant fecundity, we conducted an experiment with isogenic lines of Arabidops
is thaliana, representing a wild type and seven photomorphogenic mutants. W
e exposed all genotypes to a 3 x 3 factorial array of light intensity and w
ater availability. We documented altered plasticity to light intensity not
only for mutants insensitive to blue wavelengths, but also for mutants inse
nsitive to red and far-red wavelengths. Our results are consistent with mod
els of co-action between these two distinct photoreceptory systems. Photomo
rphogenic mutants showed altered plasticity to light intensity not only for
seedling and rosette morphology, but also for the duration of the vegetati
ve and reproductive phases. Fruit production and two other performance trai
ts showed no significant variation for plasticity to light intensity, but t
he means of all three performance traits differed significantly among genot
ypes. Notably, mean fruit production was much lower in the wild type than i
n the blue-insensitive and far-red insensitive mutants. The high fruit prod
uction of these mutants declined with decreasing water availability. In con
trast, the low fruit production of the wild type was quite stable with decl
ining water. However, we found only marginally significant variation among
genotypes for the water-mediated plasticity of fruit production. Our compar
isons of photomorphogenic mutants and wild-type plants suggest that there m
ay be significant costs associated with the photoreceptory systems. However
, the enhanced fitness of mutant genotypes may not be realizable in natural
conditions, where very low water availability or curtailed growing seasons
may be common.