An evaluation of the Biosphere-Atmosphere Transfer Scheme (BATS) snow submo
del was conducted, both in a stand-alone mode and within the National Cente
r for Atmospheric Research (NCAR) Community Climate Model version 3 (CCM3).
We evaluated, in the stand-alone mode, the performance of BATS parameteriz
ations at local scales using ground-based observations from the former Sovi
et Union and from Mammoth Mountain, California. The BATS snow scheme reprod
uces well the seasonal evolution of snow water equivalent in both sites, an
d the results for the Mammoth Mountain site compare well with those from a
more complex, physically based model (SNTHERM). In the coupled mode, we eva
luated the modelled snow cover extent, snow mass, precipitation and tempera
ture from BATS as linked to the NCAR CCM3 using available observations. The
coupled models capture the broad pattern of seasonal and geographical dist
ribution of snow cover, with better overall performance than the passive mi
crowave snow data derived from the Nimbus-7 Scanning Multi-channel Microwav
e Radiometer (SMMR) which generally underestimates snow depth. In terms of
continents, the snow mass is better simulated during the accumulation perio
d than during the melt period, which is the case for both North America and
Eurasia. The simulation of snow mass, precipitation and air temperature fo
r North America is slightly better than that for Eurasia. A rigorous evalua
tion of snow simulations in coupled land-atmosphere models requires high qu
ality global datasets of snow cover extent, snow depth and snow water equiv
alent. The available datasets and model outputs are not yet ready to fulfil
this objective. Copyright (C) 1999 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.