S. Couillard et al., Effect of combined treatment with the pure antiestrogen EM-800 and radiotherapy on the growth of human ZR-75-1 breast cancer xenografts in nude mice, CANCER RES, 59(19), 1999, pp. 4857-4863
Human breast tumors are usually composed of heterogeneous cell populations
that exhibit different sensitivities to therapeutic agents. We therefore in
vestigated the effect of treatment with various regimens of the novel pure
antiestrogen EM-800, alone or in combination with external beam radiation t
herapy, on the growth of human ZR-75-1 xenografts in athymic mice. The anim
als received a maximal dose of EM-800 (300 pg, p.o.) and/or radiotherapy at
the dose of 10 Gy, 2.5 Gy fractions were administered over a 9-day period
in four sessions of 13.7 min each (250-kilovolt Siemens with 2 mm aluminum
filtration at 90 cm from the source origin). EM-800 was administered p.o. o
nce daily, whereas radiotherapy nas repeated every 35 days. Tumor size was
expressed as a percentage of the initial tumor size, which was assigned a v
alue of 100%, Average tumor size increased by 514% in ovariectomized mice s
upplemented with estrone alone for 259 days compared with the pretreatment
value. Treatment with radiotherapy or EM-800 alone resulted in 11 and 73% d
ecreases in mean tumor size, respectively, whereas combined treatment given
simultaneously at the beginning caused a dramatic 98% decrease in tumor si
ze. The start of radiotherapy on day 35 in EM-800-treated mice, or converse
ly, the start of EM-800 in irradiated mice at the 35-day time interval, res
ulted in somewhat lower, 88% and 95%, decreases in tumor size, respectively
. In animals receiving EM-800 alone, 40% of tumors disappeared, thus indica
ting a cytotoxic effect caused by the estrogen blockade achieved with the p
ure antiestrogen, Eighty-six % of the original tumors disappeared under con
tinuous combined treatment. Most importantly, no tumor reappeared under est
rogenic stimulation after stopping treatment, thus indicating cure of 86% o
f the tumors in the group of animals who received the combination therapy.
The present data indicate that combined treatment with EM-800 and radiother
apy yields a faster response, a greater decrease in tumor size, and a highe
r percentage of complete responses or tumor disappearance (cure) than eithe
r treatment used alone. The present data also suggest that maximal benefits
are achieved when the pure antiestrogen is administered continuously, star
ting at the same tine as radiation therapy and continued without interrupti
on as adjuvant therapy. The present data also clearly show that efficient b
lockade of estrogens with a potent and pure antiestrogen is not only cytost
atic but is cytotoxic and can lead to the disappearance of an important pro
portion of tumors or cure.