Why is Butterfield's best-seller The Origins of Modern Science (1949)
such a powerful big picture, nearly impossible to move away from? Cons
idered in the context of his life, the contrast between his attacks on
Whig history and the contents of his best-seller reveals that his big
picture of science continues at the centre because of his spiritual b
eliefs and practices. Butterfield did not make explicit his Christian
(Methodist) world view to his history of science readers, although one
could infer this from his point that Christianity and the Scientific
Revolution were the most significant events in universal history, tran
scending cultural boundaries. As long as Christian beliefs and practic
es continue to be at the centre of Western Society, so will Butterfiel
d's big picture be at the centre. Western society is a Christian civil
ization. For Butterfield, the meaning of history is Christianity and T
he Origins of Modern Science is very much a Christian statement of the
evolution of knowledge acquisition in Western society. To de-centre T
he Origins would require first a de-centred view of Christianity. Copy
right (C) 1996 Elsevier Science Ltd.