Rd. Leichtentritt et Kd. Rettig, Attitudes toward euthanasia and justifying reasons of elderly Israelis andtheir family members, J PERS IN L, 4(4), 1999, pp. 317-344
The purpose of the current study was to reach an interpretive understanding
of the reasons underlying favorable and unfavorable attitudes of Israeli e
lderly adults and their family members toward euthanasia. The informants we
re 47 individuals representing 19 families who were asked for their attitud
es toward four case studies that represented withholding and withdrawing tr
eatment, active euthanasia, and physician-assisted death. Results of the gr
ounded theory analysis revealed that most of the participants favored withh
olding life-sustaining treatment and that almost half of them thought activ
e euthanasia and physician-assisted suicide were morally acceptable as long
as the decision was made by the individual patient himself or herself (vol
untary). The reasons that justified their attitude Positions were named acc
ording to six dimensions: promoting life, promoting death, self-control, de
legators, allowing to die, and one-way street. The analysis further examine
d similar reasons that were provided as justifications for attitudes by two
or more family members. These family reason dimensions were labeled accord
ing to their similarities to various ethical perspectives, including charac
ter ethics, natural laws, liberal individualism, communitarianism, benefice
nce, and casuistry. The research highlighted the importance of self-control
as a core concern of individuals and family members when addressing the mo
ral issues surrounding euthanasia.