V. Ottati et al., The effect of metaphor on processing style in a persuasion task: A motivational resonance model, J PERS SOC, 77(4), 1999, pp. 688-697
Previous research on metaphor and persuasion has suggested that metaphorica
l language elicits an assimilation effect wherein positive metaphors elicit
positive attitudes toward the communication topic and negative metaphors e
licit negative evaluations. The authors of this article propose that metaph
orical content can increase or decrease motivation to systematically scruti
nize a persuasive communication depending on the extent to which it "resona
tes" with the listener's preferences and interests. Consistent with this mo
del, 2 experiments demonstrate that a sports metaphor increases message-rel
evant elaboration and sensitivity to argument strength among individuals wh
o enjoy sports. Conversely, the sports metaphor reduces message-relevant el
aboration and sensitivity to argument strength among individuals who dislik
e sports. Findings are discussed in the context of related research that su
ggests metaphor can serve alternative functions in a persuasive communicati
on task.