OBJECTIVE: To compare the performance of different bedside tests for essent
ial tremor (ET).
BACKGROUND: Numerous tests (for example, writing, arm extension) may be use
d to elicit tremor in patients with ET. In large epidemiological surveys in
which many patients must be evaluated efficiently, knowledge about the rel
ative performance of these tests would be useful.
METHODS: 154 subjects (42 with ET and 112 control subjects) were part of a
community-based family study of ET in northern Manhattan, New York. Subject
s underwent a tremor interview and a videotaped tremor examination which in
cluded six different rests for ET. Each of the six tests was performed with
both the dominant and the nondominant arms. Two neurologists reviewed the
videotaped examination and rated the severity of tremor during each test. T
remor ratings were 0 (none), +1 (mild), +2 (moderate), and +3 (severe).
RESULTS: Among ET cases, there was considerable variation in the performanc
e of each bedside test. With some tests (nondominant arm extension), as few
as 48.8% of the ratings were >+2 and 29.8% of the ratings were a (no tremo
r). With other tests (finger-to-nose maneuver using nondominant arm), as ma
ny as 88.1% of the ratings were >+2 and only 2.4% were 0. Among the control
subjects, there was also considerable variation in the performance of each
test. Using some tests (finger-to-nose maneuver using nondominant arm), as
many as 26.3% of the ratings were >+2, 72.8% were >+1 tremor, and only 27.
2% of the ratings were 0.
CONCLUSIONS: The performance of the tests varied considerably. In settings
in which only one or two tests must be selected to screen a population, tes
ts that are most likely to be abnormal in an ET case (finger-to-nose maneuv
er) could be used. In settings in which it is also desirable to exclude nor
mal subjects, tests such as sustained arm extension, pouring water, or draw
ing a spiral could be used. Data regarding the performance of bedside tests
for diagnosing ET are central to the design of research strategies for the
clinical evaluation of patients with ET.